Encouraging Curiosity Through “What If?” Play
Encouraging Curiosity Through “What If?” Play
What Is “What If?” Play?
“What If?” play happens when children imagine possibilities that aren’t happening right now:
“What if my stuffed animal could talk?”
“What if we lived on the moon?”
“What if the floor was lava?”
“What if dinosaurs came to school?”
These hypothetical questions invite children to:
explore consequences,
stretch creativity,
practice flexible thinking,
solve imaginary problems.
This is the heart of early learning: curiosity with joyful exploration.
Why Curiosity Matters for School Readiness
Curiosity is tied to:
persistence,
innovation,
conflict resolution,
language growth,
scientific thinking.
Kids who are curious don’t just memorize — they investigate.
Teachers notice curiosity as a top predictor of:
✔ engagement
✔ confidence
✔ independence
Step 1: Answer Questions With Questions
Instead of answering everything instantly, try reflecting curiosity back.
Child: “What if the clouds fell?”
You:
“Hmm… what do you think would happen?”
This:
keeps the idea alive,
encourages reasoning,
strengthens imagination.
(Try this too: Building Curiosity Through “Why” Questions)
Step 2: Provide Space for Open-Ended Thinking
Avoid shutting down imaginative ideas with:
“That’s silly.”
“That can’t happen.”
Instead, validate:
“That’s an interesting idea!”
“What would we do next?”
Validation builds confidence in creative thinking.
Step 3: Use Puppets to Expand Scenarios
Puppets can introduce surprising “What If?” twists:
“What if my puppet grew wings?”
“What if the dinosaurs needed naps?”
“What if the robot forgot its battery?”
Children practice:
empathy,
storytelling,
logic.
(Related read: How to Use Props and Puppets to Teach Concepts)
Step 4: Bring “What If?” Into Pretend Worlds
Try posing scenarios during dramatic play:
restaurant,
doctor’s office,
astronaut mission,
animal habitat.
Example:
“What if the spaceship ran out of fuel?”
Suddenly, problem-solving enters the story.
Step 5: Use Real Objects With Imaginary Rules
With blocks:
“What if these blocks were magic portals?”
With playdough:
“What if the volcano erupted?”
Safe pretend “problems” build real cognitive skills.
Step 6: Encourage Divergent Thinking
Instead of:
“What color is the sun?”
Try:
“What if the sun were purple? How would the world change?”
There are many correct answers here. That’s the point.
Step 7: Try “What If?” Art Prompts
Art prompts build:
narrative,
remember-thinking,
emotional processing.
Examples:
“Draw a house for a giant.”
“Draw a car that swims.”
“What if your pet could talk? What would it say?”
No pressure. Just creativity.
Step 8: Add Simple Scientific Curiosity
“What If?” becomes early science when tied to observable concepts:
“What if we freeze this fruit?”
“What if we mix vinegar and baking soda?”
“What if the plant didn’t get sunlight?”
Children experiment while feeling safe to be wrong.
(Also see: Teaching Science Through Sensory Exploration)
Step 9: Build Flexible Thinking Through
Rule-Changing Games
Try:
Freeze Dance switches,
Simon Says twists,
scavenger hunts with changing goals.
Ask:
“What if the rules suddenly changed?”
Flexibility strengthens executive function.
(Related read: Using Play to Build Executive Function Skills)
Step 10: Write Mini “What If?” Stories Together
Help your child narrate:
characters,
setting,
problem,
solution.
Example:
“What if your toys came alive at night? What would they do?”
Your child practices sequencing and perspective-taking.
Why Adults Should Avoid Over-Directing
Correcting “What If?” answers can:
shut down curiosity,
shrink imagination,
replace wonder with worry.
Let the ideas be big, strange, impossible. Childhood is rehearsal for possibility.
When Children Struggle
Offer simple jumpstart questions:
“What if animals talked?”
“What if it snowed spaghetti?”
“What if we shrunk to ant-size?”
Imagination is a muscle — repetition strengthens it.
Emotional Benefits of “What If?”
Scenarios can give children:
control over feelings,
distance from fears,
safe exposure to conflict,
practice making choices.
If a puppet feels scared?
Your child practices comforting.
If a monster is sad? Your child problem-solves empathy.
Fuzzigram’s Favorite “What If?” Prompts
✅ What if pets could go to school?
✅ What if dinosaurs were tiny?
✅ What if your toys were alive when you’re gone?
✅ What if you invented a new holiday?
✅ What if a robot lived in your house?
Popular Parenting Articles
Recommended social-emotional learning tools & activities: